In the last few weeks/months I have got more immersed in the world of REST and what it means to build and have a REST application. While at first glance it may seem that REST is a lighter weight version of a web-service implementation, it is by no means the complete answer and I do not believe REST is simply a replacement of Web Services because of how they operate is different.
When developing Object applications, in whatever language, you hit a reality that if your application is successful, then it will grow beyond the confines of the machine/JMV that it runs on, and as such you have to refer to objects that are beyond a single instance of the application's memory space. This can be done using a number of different technologies such as object databases that can map the same object into different application instances, but the locks are maintained by the central server so consistency of the objects are maintained, even if the object is distributed in 100s of applications at a time.
Now technologies such as IIOP (Corba), RMI, DCOM and Web Services have been used to access objects and invoke operations on the instances to retrieve data. This essentially solves the long-wire problem of accessing an object and then returning an instance of the object, the issue here being is that typically a representation of the object that you want is returned, i.e. using Java serialization or XML and the reference to the actual instance is lost, unless you have a known object identity that you are working with.
REST adds the concept of the pointer to the SOA infrastructure in a way that any business object can be referenced by a URL and thus referenced anywhere within the internet/cloud or a single program space. This is something that is not readily available in Web Services and now makes any RESTful resource available to anyone (given the correct permissions). Now this sparks a whole debate on to how to identity a particular object and to detect duplicates etc, this is beyond the scope of this blog but will have the same techniques that are used in the object-oriented world, but now working at the cloud scale.
So now that REST gives us some new capabilities, how does this change the current implementations that you are working on? Interestingly, I think many of the challenges existing in the Web Services world still need to be addressed in the REST world, I just believe that REST is probably better able to address some of the immediate ones and in fact just like every Progress customer has another application to connect to Web Services will always be required.
The other cool thing about REST is that I can typically use the services directly from an HTML page on a browser, something that was impossible for Web Services because HTML and WSDL are not compatible. However, there is still the need to mediate REST in the same way that applied to Web-Services, for instance to be able to turn a switch to expose the same business entity as REST and Web-Service and in fact any possible protocol. Allowing external access to your business objects will require caching and a level of indirection to provide for maintenance, performance, etc., and the virtualization of the underlying technology to ensure that an object is not a manifestation of the technology that stores it, i.e. database tables and rows are not part of the object serialization. Security, Quality of Service (QoS) and Quality of Protection (QoP) are observed along with SLA commitments and the ability to monetize the object and charge accordingly. This last point maybe very interesting as it would allow organizations to potentially charge for access to their data for different reasons and allow IT to start to become a profit-center rather than just a cost-center - something that I think people will look at as they invest in the cloud.
Now I think that the promise of REST is very interesting, in more ways than Web Services was, but whether the ideal is purely based around REST or a hybrid of many technologies is going to depend on the goal of what is to be achieved. In any event, it is very exciting.
View all posts from David Millman on the Progress blog. Connect with us about all things application development and deployment, data integration and digital business.
Subscribe to get all the news, info and tutorials you need to build better business apps and sites
Copyright © 2019 Progress Software Corporation and/or its subsidiaries or affiliates.
All Rights Reserved.
Progress, Telerik, and certain product names used herein are trademarks or registered trademarks of Progress Software Corporation and/or one of its subsidiaries or affiliates in the U.S. and/or other countries. See Trademarks for appropriate markings.